1
Rules Questions and FAQs / Possible, Impossible or Possible charge move against a common Block.
« on: Oct 19, 2011, 05:31:58 PM »
Hey again fellow Maneaters.
Have another question coming up and this one has really gone to my head so I really need your opinion on this. Is it possible for a character that stands in the 2nd rank to charge out from his unit? Imo Its allowed since he got Line of Sight from there.
Anyway. That was only the first Q and a side note for that matter. The real question is how to do if the enemy moves a typical "block-unit", like harpies, 1" in front of your unit. Is it the possible to charge them with a single character that charge out from his unit? Since they are only 1" away and our Ogre bases are bigger than 1", he can't really fit in.
What to do?
Just this happened against a Dark Elves player I meet earlier today. We discussed it over and over and couldn’t find a correct way to do it. I will post some picture of the possible outcomes of my charge.
1. Here is a made-up screenshot of the situation where it all began. Butcher stands in the middle and declares the charge. Harpies holds.

2. Just a picture to show where the problem occurred.

3. Here is how I first moved my Butcher. Since it’s fairly clear that he charges in the front, I moved him to the side so he did fit. But then my opponent said that my charge move was illegal and the only way that was allowed was if my model was a flyer. I wish he wore

4. This is how we agreed to solve the situation. Since I wasn’t allowed to move to the side, we agreed that to solve it in the easiest way the harpies closed the door by turning a bit more to the other direction so the butcher could fit in the front. Didn't feel 100% correct but we both felt this was the most logical way to solve the issue.

So what are your opinions? Did we do the right thing when RAW? Or RAI? Or none of it.
A big tourney is coming up and the main reason I want to discuss this is because I want to know if it’s possible to charge out with a character from a unit even if he doesn’t fit in front? Or will it be an illegal charge? If it is legal, how would it work out?
If not, it clearly sucks.
Looking forward to hear your thoughts.
Have another question coming up and this one has really gone to my head so I really need your opinion on this. Is it possible for a character that stands in the 2nd rank to charge out from his unit? Imo Its allowed since he got Line of Sight from there.
Anyway. That was only the first Q and a side note for that matter. The real question is how to do if the enemy moves a typical "block-unit", like harpies, 1" in front of your unit. Is it the possible to charge them with a single character that charge out from his unit? Since they are only 1" away and our Ogre bases are bigger than 1", he can't really fit in.
What to do?
Just this happened against a Dark Elves player I meet earlier today. We discussed it over and over and couldn’t find a correct way to do it. I will post some picture of the possible outcomes of my charge.
1. Here is a made-up screenshot of the situation where it all began. Butcher stands in the middle and declares the charge. Harpies holds.

2. Just a picture to show where the problem occurred.

3. Here is how I first moved my Butcher. Since it’s fairly clear that he charges in the front, I moved him to the side so he did fit. But then my opponent said that my charge move was illegal and the only way that was allowed was if my model was a flyer. I wish he wore


4. This is how we agreed to solve the situation. Since I wasn’t allowed to move to the side, we agreed that to solve it in the easiest way the harpies closed the door by turning a bit more to the other direction so the butcher could fit in the front. Didn't feel 100% correct but we both felt this was the most logical way to solve the issue.

So what are your opinions? Did we do the right thing when RAW? Or RAI? Or none of it.
A big tourney is coming up and the main reason I want to discuss this is because I want to know if it’s possible to charge out with a character from a unit even if he doesn’t fit in front? Or will it be an illegal charge? If it is legal, how would it work out?
If not, it clearly sucks.
Looking forward to hear your thoughts.

